Directing to Self-Penetration
   

Six Dhamma Talks about Centering the Mind

in Non-Attachment

by

Tan Acharn Kor Khao-suan-luang

(Upasika Kee Nanayon)

Wheel No. 326 / 328

Copyright © Kandy, Buddhist Publication Society, (First BPS edition 1985)
BPS Online Edition © (2007)

For free distribution. This work may be republished, reformatted, reprinted and redistributed in any medium. However, any such republication and redistribution is to be made available to the public on a free and unrestricted basis and translations and other derivative works are to be clearly marked as such.


Contents:

Preface to the Thai Edition

Training in Renunciation

Making Dhamma One's True Concern

Mindfulness Like the Pilings of a Dam

The Battle Within

All Things Are Unworthy of Attachment

Simply Stop Right Here

Preface to the Thai Edition

Dhamma talks given to those practicing at Khao-suan-luang on the weekly Observance Day have regularly been printed, and this book continues the series. They aim to encourage and support Dhamma practice following the Way of the Lord Buddha and his Noble Disciples whose brilliance dispels the darkness of every age and time. Devotion to practice always brings great benefit in leading to the end of suffering.

I wish to acknowledge the generosity of all those who have joined together to make merit by printing this book to be given away freely as a pure gift of Dhamma to anyone interested in practice. Other books in this series have already been widely distributed to various monasteries and libraries, and as opportunity allows we hope to continue this service.

Kor Khao-suan-luang
Usom Sathan, Khao-suan-luang
Rajburi

23.4.1972

Training in Renunciation

1st November 1963

The results of one's step by step practice of self-inspection must be carefully noted, then any imprudence or mistake in one's daily life can be corrected as much as possible. If we don't keep to a high standard, our mind will continually decline because of selfishness. Without careful and thorough examination, this disease of selfishness will spread its infection everywhere; therefore we must continually keep on with our task of self-inspection. Whenever we are careless in this and selfishness arises, we must make sure we completely eradicate it, especially if it should arise strongly. Even when it is more subtle it must be thoroughly searched out. If we do not destroy this virulent disease inside ourselves, our practice will not be in accord with the Lord Buddha's Teaching.

It is therefore necessary to have complete self-inspection based upon and developing from the Five and Eight Precepts. Normally, the precepts can lower selfishness at one level and our mind development can eliminate it at a medium level, as we should all understand quite well. Finally, however, we have to use mindfulness and wisdom (satipa––‡) to eradicate the selfishness which results from not seeing the truth of impermanence, suffering, and not-self. We must consider this repeatedly. When interest intensifies, the defilements, craving and clinging, and the self in its various manifestations can be eliminated. In not knowing that things are impermanent and deceitful comes the desire to grasp hold of them and take them always as our treasure. This disease is difficult to treat simply because we would rather examine others than ourselves!

To turn and examine oneself so as to catch and see that Ôself' with its intrigues, hiding insidiously deep in one's natureÑthis requires strong and thorough mindfulness and wisdom. But to actually get rid of it isn't so easy and really one only sees its deceit and desires. These multifarious ways of greed are worthy of great attention and need to be carefully examined, for without introspection one's practise will veer off-course and end by actually facilitating and increasing one's sense of self.

Initially, so as not to feed and inflate this sense of self, we have to be content with what we have. There should be no need for things, from the crudest to the most refined, no matter how much one is attracted to them. But everyone must see and understand this for himself, which isn't easy as it is all very insidious. The difficulty is compounded because the self is always looking for distractions to involve us in. Should we enquire what it is grasping for, what it is in turmoil over Ñit just pretends not to have heard. It is interested in just wanting more and more, without end.

A basic characteristic of the human being is to be clever in acquiring this and that. The defilements (kilesa) only have this cleverness in getting but not in giving up or sacrificing. If only this could be changed around so that one became clever in giving away! It would bring such great benefits because one would stop grasping at things and gradually, with strong contemplation, destroy the attachment. If one stops the defilements from talking their fill by cutting off their food, this can be considered as following the Way of the Noble Disciple (Arahant). But the other way, the way of deception and sponsoring self, makes one a firm follower of Mara, the Evil One, who personifies the defilements, and instead of giving away one just endlessly acquires and consumes things.

There are, therefore, these two ways and we must examine ourselves to see the acute disease of selfishnessÑwith its getting clevernessÑwhich lies within us all. Yet if we aren't sharp enough, we will be fooled by self's guiles; "the more the merrier" as Mara would say. You must ask yourself, "Am I really following the way to Enlightenment or is it the way of Mara and selfishness? On which path does my cleverness really lie?" This is something we must always question.

With regard to the household stores in this area which have been donated for the general use of those who come here to practise Dhamma, one should be careful never to appropriate any such communal property for oneselfÑone must always ask first. If one grabs this and that to be as comfortable as possible, then even though one may have acted unthinkingly this is the same as theft. The communal household utensils here should therefore not be requisitioned as one's own; even those things donated to you should, on occasion, be brought out and shared. Then there is no attachment and one does not plan just for one's own convenience. Otherwise the instinct of Ôself'Ñwhich must appropriate things to itself Ñis very insidious and cunning and it's difficult to see its villainy. One mistakenly accepts "the more I can get the better." Such selfishness puts one under the power of Mara.

Now that we have become disciples of the Lord Buddha, how can we possibly be like that? If we should see the greed arisen in ourselves become particularly avaricious, then the only way out is to give that thing up. Relinquish it! Under no circumstance should it be quietly appropriated on the side. Absolutely not! I will tell you plainly, anyone living in a religious community who behaves like this will only go from bad to worse, because there is no sense of shame or fear of doing evil. Without these two fundamental principles as a foundation how can Dhamma possibly be built up? Though one might be knowledgeable and skilled in reciting the scriptures, one can't even put right such an underlying fault of character. A character which knows no bounds to its greed really seems disgusting or, at least, the disease which infects that mind is. What can we do to cleanse such a mind? Anyway, to associate with extremely selfish people will inflame the disease still more and it will infect deep into the mind.

This remains a hidden subject which people don't wish to speak about. It's not pleasant talk, rather, it is disturbing with sinister implications. Only with mindfulness and wisdom in examining oneself will one be able to know the deceit of the defilements and greed. How can this all be destroyed? It is not something which one can be half-hearted about; one must renounce and give away as much as possible. Those things which are involved in supporting such selfishness must be given up. You shouldn't agree amongst yourselves that each grabs as much as he can, but rather encourage one another to give as much as possible. If you don't then the mind will fall into anguish because you turn and infect yourself with the dirt and disease of selfishness. And who can possibly come and treat you?

When one decides to examine this malignant disease, one must remember all this for nobody else wants to discuss it with you. Even though they are all saturated with the same infection, they prefer to talk of other things! The giving away of various things from time to time is relatively easy, but to relinquish the self is both extremely difficult and profound. Nevertheless the effort is worthwhile because this self is the sole source of all suffering. Should this root not be destroyed, it will continue to sprout and flourish. We must therefore turn and catch this self.

The Lord Buddha has laid down the Recollection of the Four Requisites (of life), which for the monks are robe material, alms food, shelter, and medicine. He said that if they weren't considered merely as material exigencies, as dh‡tu freed of all ideas of self, then the yellow robe, the lump of rice, the hut and medicines would all burst into flame. Even though we may not be monks and only beginners in Dhamma practice, if we really have the determination to destroy the defilements and Ôself,' then there's no loss in trying to follow a similar basic rule. If we don't, imagine how the defilements, craving, clinging, and the self are boundlessly growing. So we have to make our choice: simply to follow the old way or to try hard to turn towards the end of self. This is very much your own concern. Turning to examine internally is difficult, but one has only to try carefully a little and great benefit will always come from it. When one can actually catch the deceit of self in the act of plunging one still deeper into suffering, and there and then wipe it out, this is truly a reward beyond price.

If we do not realize this eradication, this giving up of self, then the basis for continual suffering is laid and grows. By not bringing it in for examination it grows freely. Even though we can quote and recite the scripturesÑand even skillfully teach othersÑstill the mind is impure and confused. When we can see all this clearly then we will feel revulsion with all this desire. Then we can begin to give and make sacrificesÑhowever difficult it seems!Ñnot allowing suffering a hold. Thereupon each small renunciation builds its own reward in the mind until there is complete victory.

Those having a strong tendency to meannessÑwhich is a specific defilementÑseem to be unable to give anything up. They are reluctant to examine themselves and admit that there really exists within them such a severe disease as selfishness. If they would frequently examine carefully inside themselves, such a defilement wouldn't dare to show its face, but if they are negligent then the defilement will grow strong and bold and be capable of the most selfish and despicable acts. Such people are then capable of appropriating the property of a community such as we have here for their own selfish purposes.

When we turn around and constantly try to examine our minds, we will persist in giving up our unworthy attachments. Then whatever we do is Dhamma and will all be of help to our companions in (this world of) birth, illness, old age and death. Once selfishness is expurgated, through this single advance we can come to the aid of others without caring about any hardships involved. Without self we are truly on the noble way.

The practice of Dhamma needs orderliness in daily life without which it is unseemly. Another point here is that shortcomings in behaviour allow the defilements to arise more easily. Orderliness helps to arouse mindfulness which may allow one to forestall the defilements. Disregard for rules and regulations is valueless whereas conscientiously abiding by them can bring benefit. They give one a sense of how to respond correctly to every situation, which is necessary because we don't yet really understand by ourselves. The Lord Buddha knew the situation from every side whereas we are surrounded by darkness and ignorance. This means we can't be sure of ourselvesÑeither externally or internallyÑand so must depend on Dhamma and the Way it points out to us. But whether one is to follow Dhamma or wander astray must be decided each one for himself.

Those who wish to get rid of their own defilements and suffering and who have vigilance as an asset of mind must be diligent and persevere. Wherever they venture they only seem to meet the scorching fire of suffering, so finally they stop, turn and set themselves the task of struggling to be free. Without a clear and thorough understanding of oneself, the defilements will thrive and spread their virulent infection which can only bring more and more suffering. We must therefore reinforce our mindfulness and wisdom for no other instrument can fight and destroy the defilements.

The unremitting effort to train the mind needs mindfulness and wisdom to point the way. Half-heartedness is merely a waste of time and one remains an unmitigated fool. When one realizes this, the benefits from the resulting effort are immense; eventually one can destroy the defilements, relinquish one's attachment and the mind transcends suffering. But if one can't make this gain then one will be swept away by the power of craving and defilements. By being negligent and careless they lead one by the nose, they pull one here and drag one there. Therefore, the Lord Buddha emphasized in many ways that one must relinquish, sacrifice and be uninvolved, for these are the instruments to cut out the cancer from the mind.

This kind of malignant disease is very insidious and though it may make itself felt a little, it's usually not enough to alert one and eventually it triumphs. Sometimes one even submits to its terms with alacrity. Therefore, one's examination must be very circumspect and careful, otherwise it's like plugging one hole in a leaking boat only to find it's leaking elsewhere. There are six holes or aperturesÑthe eyes, ears, nose, tongue, body and mindÑand if we have no control over them, they are left open to follow after emotions, which causes great suffering. One must use mindfulness and wisdom to seek out and review the true situation inside oneself and this must become the most important activity throughout the day. Our life is for working on the elimination of the defilements, not for anything else. Yet the defilements and suffering continue to hover about and if we aren't equal to them they will burn us. We must pull ourselves around and question how to remedy this, which will lead to great results. While we still have breath and our bodies are not yet rotting in their coffin we must take counsel and search for a way to eradicate the root-infection of this terrible disease, the germ of defilements and craving. This cancer that has eaten deeply into the mind can only be cured with Dhamma. The Lord Buddha prescribed the different properties of his various Dhamma medicines. Each one of us must carefully select and compound what is correct and most suitable, then use it to destroy the root infection. All this necessitates great circumspection.

Should one's self-inspection still be insufficient to destroy the defilements they will grow stronger and burn like an invisible fire inside the mind. Introspection is the extinguisher to use, so that when we notice greed arising for an object, we must snuff it out and relinquish it. Now look at the mind, is it free or entangled in turmoil? If we don't persevere it can only end in our getting burnt. No matter how smart we think we are, we succumb to greed. Greed seizes the commander's place and we make no attempt to drive it out and even go out to receive it with compliments. The mind is then the oppressed slave of desire. It has fallen into delusion with grasping this and that, leaving no obvious way out of such wretched entanglement. We don't know how to escape this dilemma which viciously encircles our mind.

We are trapped by our lack of true resolve and finally, when we are at wit's end, we become slaves to the defilements as before. The more often we submit to them the more their power grows. The only true way to overthrow them is to strenuously bring mindfulness and wisdom to bear and examine the suffering they bring from all angles until the mind refuses to stay a slave. It's no use just making an external show of it because the greater the fuss the more stubborn the defilements become, and yet we also can't be half-hearted about it. One must have the appropriate response for whatever the situation. One can't just go in with massive good intention to wipe them out, but must first carefully focus and enhance one's mindfulness and wisdom. This all requires great circumspection and these are all important points to remember.

When one's all-round mindfulness and wisdom are still insufficient and not reinforced, then the defilements will be overwhelming. If one can persistently build up mindfulness and wisdom then, in their turn, the strength of the defilements will gradually fall away. One notices that the mind that previously was confused is now resolute and sees the impermanence of things more clearly so that they can be let go of and relinquished. This insight into impermanence restrengthens mindfulness and wisdom to an even deeper discernment; yet this penetration must be truly focused, otherwise the slightest inattention will break it up. If it doesn't wander off target, even for a moment, then this is truly the way to control the defilements, but carelessness means it can never affect them and they will regroup stronger than ever.

Mindfulness and clear comprehension must be developed in every posture, with every breath. We must make the effort so that the mind is attentive and doesn't drift away following the various emotions, or lose itself in confusion arising from concocting thoughts. One should be forewarned here about the tendency to think "I know!" when one really doesn't. Until the mind penetrates to true insight, there must always be doubt and uncertainty; but when one truly starts to see, then doubts fall away and one no longer speculates about it. One truly knows. Can you be certain that you have true insight? When the mind truly sees, the defilements and suffering are really eliminated, but if one just thinks one seesÑwhilst having no real insight of mindÑthen one can't possibly destroy the defilements and suffering.

For the mind to genuinely understand, it must investigate in every posture, with every breath. It will then be equal to stopping the emotions and those tendencies which continually fabricate notions without reason or value under the compulsion of delusion. Without true determination practice becomes halfhearted and this leads to distractionÑand a waste of valuable timeÑall being nothing more than delusion. We must turn our vision inside ourselves and persevere until we see clearly. Once we are adept it's actually more enjoyable to look inside than out. Externally there is just the dissolution of things seenÑwhy be so engrossed in that? But the inner eye can penetrate to the clear light and then to the Truth of Dhamma. By seeing the nature of the dissolution of all sankharas (which determine compounded things) new insight will arise as to that nature which doesn't deteriorate, a nature which can't be altered but just is.

This insight penetrates into the mind, where the desire for things is activated and that which blocks out Dhamma abides. When this concocting stops one sees the nature of mind that is without the fire and anguish of desire. This can be seen anytime, when one focuses properly and with determination! One can see other things, why not this? Just truly look and you will certainly see!

But one must look correctly to be able to penetrate, otherwise one will see nothing. If one grasps at things which goes against the basic principles of true knowledge and then tries to go straight to the truth, it's probable that one will get all twisted and an element of pride, or something similar, will insinuate itself. The only way is to see the arising and ceasing of things, merely seeing and understanding without grasping. See! This is the way to freedom from attachment. It has been said, "See the world as if it were free and empty," and we must similarly see our emotions as they arise and cease as free and empty. When the mind truly realizes the transience of things, the deceit of the world and our emotions, it doesn't grasp them any more. This is the free mind. There are many levels to this but even a temporary experience is still of benefit; just don't go and grasp after anything!

The free mind that is called vimokkha--true and final release--we find described in one of the scriptures we chant, the Solasapa–h‡, as "vimokkha is not subject to change." Those levels of free mind which change are not true vimokkha and we must continue to examine each level and press for the fruit, which is always freedom from attachment. It doesn't matter how many levels one has to work through until it finally doesn't change, which is when it is without aim or attachment for anything. This is the true way to penetrative insight. May all of you who practise Dhamma work tirelessly so as to see and know this truth.

 

Making Dhamma One's True Concern

16th November 1963

Every one of us has suffering, and the most important task of our life is to get rid of it. The defilements besiege the mind which, lacking study of Dhamma, is left helpless. They continually scorch the mind with suffering and unless we turn to Dhamma it will be consumed throughout this life and on into the next. Only Dhamma practice can extinguish and release us from suffering.

This practice of Dhamma is just constant self-examination because the body and mind are the basis of our existence. The state of changing--which they naturally exhibit--needs correct investigation, otherwise one goes the unthinking normal way, understanding nothing and grasping after things which can only compound one's suffering. But this is difficult to see and needs one's full attention and concern. In examining the unrest and anxiety of the mind, one finds it arises from the disease of greed, hatred and delusion. The desiring of things brings only turmoil to the mind; it is like being infected with a virulent disease.

It's normal for us to be afraid of bodily disease, but the disease of the defilements which disturbs and depresses the mind doesn't concern us at all. We don't choose to realize the seriousness of this infection and sometimes in our ignorance make it even worse. To actually get down to eliminating the defilements is therefore difficult and unattractive, especially with the myriad distractions outside which stir up desire. The indifferent common man just spins with his desires making the mind dizzy and unbalanced all the time. This is plainly suffering and torment, yet if we don't concern ourselves with this affliction, don't struggle to overcome the tendency to follow our desires, then we must abjectly submit to it. It's because we are unaware that the defilements have already overpowered and infected the mind that this disease is so difficult to see.

One must turn one's attention from external things and fix it on one's own body and mind. Whether mind or body, name or matter, it's all subject to impermanence and change; but this is difficult for the ordinary person to realize. It's like what we think of as the growth of a man, from his mother's womb onwards there is continual change and transformation so that this growth really means change. Nothing is immutable in this world.

The decline and decay of the body and material things shouldn't be so difficult to notice but still it escapes our attention. The mind and mental states are constantly changing, yet instead of seeing this, whenever we experience a sight or sound, we only grasp at the object, which drops us down to even more suffering.

If we could penetrate to the experience of sights, sounds, smells, tastes, tangibles and mind objects, we would find a continual change, a constant arising and passing away. How does the old emotional object pass away, how does a new one arise? How is it that the mind is overpowered by the defilements into conceivings and imaginings that proliferate out of hand? But we pay no interest to such matters and are consequently overwhelmed by suffering, which extends into actions and speech full of intense greed, hatred and delusion. This incessant torment of the defilements--hotter than the hottest fire--can only be relieved through the practice of Dhamma. But the ordinary worldling, though being roasted alive, behaves as if he is immune to the fire and pays it no attention. He even smiles and thinks himself content in habitually grasping at transient things as Ôme' and Ômine.' He doesn't realize that whatever he grasps at and falls in love with is forever out of reach, edging towards dissolution. This all needs the deepest examination so as to see the truth of it and not fall into attachment and delusion.

People learn from the scriptures of such diseases as the fetters (sa’yojana) or underlying tendencies (anusaya) but they don't turn to check for them in themselves. One takes up words and translates their definitions, yet one doesn't see that sakk‡yadiþþhi--the wrong view of holding to personality--is the direct source of all one's suffering and torment. Not only does one not comprehend this plain truth, but one even turns and submits to upholding such wrong view without any consideration. This is why the mind is in such a state of profound ignorance.

It is normal for people to have knowledge about many things, sometimes to the extent that they can't rest and must be forever researching new matters. They know what's good, what's right--they know it all! Whatever the subject, they manage to concoct an answer, finally spiralling out into wild conceptualizations. They simply know too much! This style of knowledge is that of the defilements and craving; its antidote is the knowledge arising from mindfulness and wisdom which penetrates to the truth of the mind. Should one give free rein to the obsession of wild imaginings, the mind will exhaust itself and one will eventually suffer a nervous breakdown. If one allows oneself to get into such a state, one will end up insane, in some cases staying deluded till one's death and on being reborn returning to that same delusion. This occurs because of a lack of critical examination and from not relying on the application of Dhamma. Tranquilizers and such drugs for the mentally ill merely relieve the external symptoms and do not get to the root cause. A radical cure depends on the control of one's own mind, using mindfulness and wisdom to brake and critically check the mind and to free it from its delusions. This is the complete cure of Dhamma.

That Dhamma practice can cure every kind of illness should merit some thought. Each stage in one's understanding of Dhamma depends on mindfulness and wisdom. Those who show no interest in Dhamma, no matter how great their knowledge of worldly matters, fall under the domination of the defilements, subject to birth, old age, sickness and death. Once one understands Dhamma following the Lord Buddha, the mind will become bright, calm and pure. This knowledge is of far more value than that acquired for making one's livelihood, and that obtained by being pleasurably--but temporarily!--engrossed in various entertainments.

When one comes to constantly examine one's mind, one sees that when anxiety arises the mind is not free and will not accept the truth of the Lord Buddha's words: "Go out from desire in happiness." Being burned alive in the maw of desire through gratification in the five sense strands--sight, sound, smell, taste, touch--is not going out from desire with happiness. But if one correctly sees that the penalty of desire is suffering, then it no longer satisfies and the mind is freed from desire. At that moment, when the mind is unattached to sense objects and is free of desire, one can penetrate to more profound levels and truly know whether it is really happiness. The free mind will know of itself that happiness is not being overwhelmed by suffering or aroused to passion. The mind without passion will immediately incline solely towards freedom. Is this what you want, or are you satisfied with lust and insatiable desire? Consider carefully and make your choice.

Bending the mind towards freedom and release from entanglement in passion and lust brings a natural state of purity and calm. Surely, compared to this freedom and happiness, the turmoil of sense desires will seem loathsome and repellent. If this isn't reflected upon, one will become absorbed and lost in never-ending desires and passions, caught and confined in the cage of craving. Held in the grip of this disease so difficult to cure, isn't it high time you turned to radically curing it by destroying its root infection?

When the mind fixes on a desired object one must reflect and see the harm and suffering which arise and compare it with the happiness of the mind freed from desire. One must constantly examine this suffering and freedom from suffering in one's own mind, attending to it with every in and out breath. The principle is set down in the scriptures in the Foundations of Mindfulness, which describes many different ways to examine and reflect. But if one doesn't actually apply them in one's practice, no matter how many of the texts one reads, it will be of no benefit. One will just continue groping along in the dark, understanding nothing. To detect this insidious disease requires mindfulness and wisdom, and these must be nurtured and applied so that they become well established. If one only does this sporadically and irresolutely, one will always end in negligence and make no progress in Dhamma practice. And it is just this progress which leads to a lessening of suffering and a decline in desire, as one will see for oneself. One realizes that the most direct way of practice is constant reflection and examination, and sees how this can be applied best in one's daily life. Those of us here who devote our lives to Dhamma through following the training rule of chastity (brahmacariya) must especially consider this carefully. This way of Dhamma practice needs earnest application of mindfulness and wisdom, persevering until true knowledge arises. But initially how should one investigate so that new understanding may arise where previously there was ignorance? When the mind is possessed by ignorance and delusion, one can't relax or be indifferent but must concern oneself energetically with escaping from that which brings harm and suffering. One must discern what it is that brings brightness and clarity to the mind.

If this isn't done the mind will tend to be seduced by surrounding sense objects and one is left with just scholarly knowledge and talk. In fact, one's mind truly doesn't know what is what, and any scrap of insight which does genuinely arise will not be followed up. One relaxes, becomes preoccupied with things, and neglects the practice. Therefore it is important to be very careful about this and bring mindfulness and wisdom to bear so that they can be steadily trained and perfected. When one can penetrate to the truth of impermanence, suffering and not-self, even if just for a moment, one sees that this is truly the perfect way to extinguish all suffering. Whatever remains undiscerned must be earnestly investigated and related to what one already knows. This leads to disattachment from self and others, from Ômine' and Ôhis.' Just a momentary insight gives value to one's life, otherwise one remains in the continual darkness of ignorance and ceaseless imaginings. The mind being caught in constant turmoil is a wretched state of affairs.

Meditation must therefore be steadfastly developed. One must build it up as an asset of the mind and not be concerned only with eating, sleeping and other bad habits. One must watch over the mind so that it stays under the direction of mindfulness and wisdom, always pulling it back and never leading it out to other concerns which are a waste of time. A first step in the practice is the code of conduct, necessary because otherwise things only slide into distraction and confusion. One must therefore place oneself under precepts and discipline which can bring great benefit. One then comes to see that this life is only for training oneself for the elimination of one's defilements and suffering before the body is laid out in its coffin. Without this concern for practice and for finding a suitably quiet place, the mind will tend to over-extend itself with notions of conceit. Therefore we must all decide on the way to go, blocking the wandering of the mind after sense objects and emotions, and bringing it back to investigate within oneself so as to steadily develop calm and tranquility.

The Lord Buddha rightly set down various methods in developing meditation, including mindfulness of breathing. If we should not take one of these methods as a basis for practice, though it's still possible to gain results, they will be unsteady and fleeting. But with a basis of practice to aid one, the mind can be brought under the control of mindfulness and clear comprehension, without fading into distraction. How should we each go about this to obtain the desired results? In one's daily life, how can one improve one's practice? These questions warrant great concern and consideration. Don't be careless and forgetful! Whatever one does in one's practice--including guarding the sense doors (indriya-sa’vara)--must be followed through steadfastly without vacillation or distraction. Otherwise time flies by, one's life ebbs away, and one achieves nothing. Inattentive and half-hearted, how can you expect to escape from suffering? What a waste! Be earnest!

Such concern, when it arises authentically, enables one to right oneself and steadily wears away one's distraction. The investigation should centre on impermanence, the suffering involved in such change, and the lack of self in all of it. One then must focus on the central point of knowing and penetrate so as to clearly understand impermanence, suffering, and not-self in both body and mind. When one succeeds in clearly realizing this, then one can truly be called wise, awakened and happy through Dhamma. If it is genuine insight, then one no longer feels any attachment or involvement with anything. One is free from feelings of Ôme' and Ômine.' Does this sound interesting? I don't speak of trivial matters, this is serious--I tell you plainly!--and you must concern yourselves seriously. It's no use half-hearted listening, you must try to gain insight within yourself. This brings such great rewards that it deserves your special attention. Above all things concentrate your attention on this. May Dhamma be the guiding light in your life.

Mindfulness Like the Pilings of a Dam

November 6, 1970

Discussing the practice is more useful than discussing anything else because it gives rise to insight. If we follow the practice step by step we can read ourselves, continually deciphering things within us. As you read yourself through probing and investigating the harm and suffering caused by defilement, craving, and attachment, there will be times when you come to true knowledge, enabling you to grow dispassionate and let go. The mind will then immediately grow still, with none of the mental concoctions that used to have the run of the place through your lack of self-investigation.

The principles of self-investigation are our most important tools. We have to make a concerted effort to master them at all times, with special emphasis on using mindfulness to focus on the mind and bring it to centered concentration. If we don't focus on keeping the mind centered or neutral as its basic stance, it will wander off in various ways in pursuit of preoccupations or sensory contacts, giving rise to turmoil and restlessness. But when we practice restraint over the sensory doors by maintaining continuous mindfulness in the heart, it's like driving in the pilings for a dam. If you've ever seen the pilings for a dam, you'll know that they're driven deep, deep into the ground so that they're absolutely firm and immovable. But if you drive them into mud, they're easily swayed by the slightest contact. This should give us an idea of how firm our mindfulness should be in supervising the mind to make it stable, able to withstand sensory contact without liking or disliking its objects.

The firmness of your mindfulness is something you have to maintain continuously in your every activity, with every in-and-out breath. The mind will stop being scattered in search for preoccupations. If you don't manage this, then the mind will get stirred up whenever there's sensory contact, like a rudderless ship going wherever the wind and waves will take it. This is why you need mindfulness to guard the mind at every moment. If you can make mindfulness constant, in every activity, the mind will be continuously neutral, ready to probe and investigate for insight.

As a first step in driving in the pilings for our dam--in other words, in making mindfulness firm--we have to focus on neutrality as our basic stance. There's nothing you have to think about. Simply make the mind solid in its neutrality. If you can do this continuously, that's when you'll have a true standard for your investigation, because the mind will have gathered into concentration. But this concentration is something you have to watch over carefully to make sure it's not just oblivious indifference. Make the mind firmly established and centered so that it doesn't get absentminded or distracted as you sit in meditation. Sit straight, maintain steady mindfulness, and there's nothing else you have to do. Keep the mind firm and neutral, not thinking of anything at all. Make sure this stability stays continuous. When anything pops up, no matter how, keep the mind neutral. For example, if there's a feeling of pleasure or pain, don't focus on the feeling. Simply focus on the stability of the mind--and there will be a sense of neutrality in that stability.

If you're careful not to let the mind get absentminded or distracted, its concentration will become continuous. For example, if you're going to sit for an hour of meditation, focus on centering the mind like this for the first half hour and then make sure it doesn't wander off anywhere until the hour is up. If you change positions, it's simply an outer change in the body, while the mind is still firmly centered and neutral each moment you're standing, sitting, lying down, or whatever.

Mindfulness is the key factor in all of this, keeping the mind from concocting thoughts or labeling things. Everything has to stop. Keep this foundation snug and stable with every in-and-out breath. Then you can relax your focus on the breath while keeping the mind in the same state of neutrality. Relax your heavy focus so that it feels just right with the breath. The mind will be able to stay in this state for the entire hour, free from any thoughts that might wander off the path. Then keep an eye out to see that no matter what you do or say, the mind stays solidly in its normal state of inward knowing.

If the mind is stable within itself, you're protected on all sides. When sensory contacts come, you stay focused on being aware of your mental stability. Even if there are any momentary slips in your mindfulness, you get right back to the stability of the mind. Other than that, there's nothing you have to do. The mind will let go without your having to do anything else. The way you used to like this, hate that, turn left here, turn right there, won't be able to happen. The mind will stay neutral, equanimous, just right. If mindfulness lapses, you get right back to your focus, recognizing when the mind is centered and neutral toward its objects and then keeping it that way.

The pilings for the dam of mindfulness have to be driven in so that they're solid and secure with your every activity. Keep working at this no matter what you're doing. If you can train the mind so that stability is its basic stance, it won't get into mischief. It won't cause you any trouble. It won't concoct thoughts. It will be quiet. Once it's quiet and centered, it'll grow more refined and probe in to penetrate within itself, to know its own state of concentration from within.

As for sensory contacts, those are things outside--appearing only to disappear--so it's not interested. This can make cravings disband. Even when we change positions as pains arise in the body, the mind in that moment is stable, focused not on the pains but on its own stability. When you change positions, there will be physical and mental reactions as the circulation improves and pleasant feelings arise in place of the pains, but the mind won't get snagged on either the pleasure or the pain. It will simply stay stable: centered and firm in its neutrality. This stability can easily help you abandon the cravings that lie latent in connection with all feelings. But if you don't keep the mind centered in advance like this, craving will create issues, provoking the mind into a turmoil, wanting to change things so as to get this or that kind of happiness.

If we practice in this way repeatedly, hammering at this point over and over again, it's like driving pilings into the ground. The deeper we can drive them, the more immovable they'll be. That's when you'll be able to withstand sensory contacts. Otherwise, the mind will start boiling over with its thought concoctions in pursuit of sights, sounds, smells, tastes, and tactile sensations. Sometimes it keeps concocting the same old senseless issues over and over again. This is because the pilings of mindfulness aren't yet firmly in place. The way we've been stumbling through life is due to the fact that we haven't really practiced to the point where mindfulness is continuous enough to make the mind firmly centered and neutral. So we have to make our dam of mindfulness solid and secure.

This centeredness of mind is something we should develop with every activity, with every in-and-out breath. This way we'll be able to see through our illusions, all the way into the truths of inconstancy and not-self. Otherwise, the mind will go straying off here and there like a mischievous monkey--yet even monkeys can be caught and trained to perform tricks. In the same way, the mind is something that can be trained, but if you don't tie it to the post of mindfulness and give it a taste of the stick, it'll be very hard to tame.

When training the mind, you shouldn't force it too much, nor can you simply let it go its habitual ways. You have to test yourself to see what gets results. If you don't get your mindfulness focused, it'll quickly go running out after preoccupations or easily waver under the impact of its objects. When people let their minds simply drift along with the flow of things, it's because they haven't established mindfulness as a solid stance. When this is the case, they can't stop. They can't grow still. They can't be free. This is why we have to start out by driving in the pilings for our dam so that they're good and solid, keeping the mind stable and centered whether we're sitting, standing, walking, or lying down. This stability will then be able to withstand everything. Your mindfulness will stay with its foundation, just like a monkey tied to a post: It can't run off or get into mischief. It can only circle the post to which its leash is tied.

Keep training the mind until it's tame enough to settle down and investigate things, for if it's still scattered about, it's of no use at all. You have to train it until it's familiar with what inner stability is like, for your own instability and lack of commitment in training it is what allows it to get all entangled with thought-concoctions, with things that arise and then pass away. You have to get it to stop. Why is it so mischievous? Why is it so scattered? Why does it keep wandering off? Get in under control! Get it to stop, to settle down and grow centered!

At this stage you all have practiced enough to gain at least a taste of centered concentration. The next step is to use mindfulness to maintain it in your every activity, so that even if there are any distractions, they last only for a moment and don't turn into long issues. Keep driving in the pilings until they're solid every time there's an impact from external objects, or so that the mental concoctions that go straying out from within are all brought to stillness in every way.

This training isn't really all that hard. The important point is that, whichever of the many meditation subjects you choose, you stay mindful and aware of the mind state that's centered and neutral. If, when the mind goes straying out after objects, you keep bringing it back to its centeredness over and over again, the mind will eventually be able to stay firmly in its stance. In other words, its mindfulness will become constant, ready to probe and investigate, because when the mind really settles down, it gains the power to read the facts within itself clearly. If it's not centered, it can jumble everything up to fool you, switching from this issue to that, from this role to that; but if it's centered, it can disband everything--all defilements, cravings, and attachments--on every side.

So what this practice comes down to is how much effort and persistence you put into getting the mind firmly centered. Once it's firm, then when there arise all the sufferings and defilements that would otherwise get it soiled and worked up, it can withstand them just as the pilings of a dam can withstand windstorms without budging. You have to be clearly aware of this state of mind so that you won't go out liking this or hating that. This state will then become your point of departure for probing and investigating so as to gain the insight that sees clearly all the way through--but you have to make sure that this centeredness is continuous. Then you won't have to think about anything. Simply look right in, deeply and subtly.

The important point is that you get rid of absentmindedness and distractions. This in itself gets rid of a lot of delusion and ignorance, and leaves no opening for craving to create any issues that will stir up the mind and set it wandering. This is because we've established our stance in advance. Even if we lose our normal balance a little bit, we get right back to focusing on the stability of our concentration. If we keep at this over and over again, the stability of the mind with its continuous mindfulness will enable us to probe into the truths of inconstancy, stress, and not-self.

In the beginning, though, you don't have to do any probing. It's better simply to focus on the stability of your stance, for if you start probing when the mind isn't really centered and stable, you'll end up scattered. So focus on making centeredness the basic level of the mind and then start probing in deeper and deeper. This will lead to insights that grow more and more telling and profound, bringing the mind to a state of freedom within itself, or to a state where it is no longer hassled by defilement.

This in itself will bring about true mastery over the sense doors. At first, when we started out, we weren't able to exercise any real restraint over the eyes and ears, but once the mind becomes firmly centered, then the eyes, ears, nose, tongue, and body are automatically brought under control. If there's no mindfulness and concentration, you can't keep your eyes under control, because the mind will want to use them to look and to see, it will want to use the ears to listen to all kinds of things. So instead of exercising restraint outside, at the senses, we exercise it inside, right at the mind, making the mind firmly centered and neutral at all times. Regardless of whether you're talking or whatever, the mind's focus stays in place. Once you can do this, you'll regard the objects of the senses as meaningless. You won't have to take issue with things, thinking, "This is good, I like it. This is bad, I don't like it. This is pretty; that's ugly." The same holds true with the sounds you hear. You won't take issue with them. You focus instead on the neutral, uninvolved centeredness of the mind. This is the basic foundation for neutrality.

When you can do this, everything becomes neutral. When the eye sees a form, it's neutral. When the ear hears a sound, it's neutral--the mind is neutral, the sound is neutral, everything is all neutral--because we've closed five of the six sense doors and then settled ourselves in neutrality right at the mind. This takes care of everything. Whatever the eye may see, the ear may hear, the nose may smell, the tongue may taste, or the body may touch, the mind doesn't take issue with anything at all. It stays centered, neutral, and impartial. Take just this much and give it a try.

For the next seven days I want you to make a special point of focusing mindfulness right at the mind, for this is the end of the rainy season, the period when the lotus and water lily bloom after the end of the Rains Retreat. In the Buddha's time he would have the senior monks train the new monks throughout the Rains Retreat and then meet with him when the lotuses bloom. I've mentioned this before and I want to mention it again as a way of encouraging you to develop a stable foundation for the mind. If its stability is continuous, then it too will have to bloom--to bloom because it's not burned, disturbed, or provoked by the defilements. So make a special effort during the next seven days to see how you can manage to observe and investigate the centered, neutral state of mind continuously at all times. Of course, if you fall asleep, you fall asleep; but even then, when you lie down to sleep, try to observe how you can keep the mind centered and neutral at all times until you doze off. When you wake up, the movements of the mind will still remain in that centered, neutral state. Give it a try, so that your mind will be able to grow calm and peaceful, disbanding its defilements, cravings, sufferings--everything. Then notice to see whether or not it's beginning to bloom.

The sense of refreshment bathing the mind that comes as part of the peace of mind undisturbed by defilement will arise of its own accord without your having to do anything aside from keeping the mind stable and centered. This is your guarantee: If the mind is really stable in its concentration, the defilements won't be able to burn it or mess with it. In other words, desire won't be able to provoke it. When concentration is stable, the fires of passion, aversion, and delusion won't be able to burn it. Try to see within yourself how the stability of the mind can withstand these things, disbanding the stress, putting out the flames. But you'll have to be earnest in practicing, in making an effort to keep mindfulness truly continuous. This isn't something to play at. You can't let yourself be weak, for if you're weak you won't be able to withstand anything. You'll simply follow the provocations of defilement and craving.

The practice is a matter of stopping so that the mind can settle down and stand fast. It's not a matter of getting into mischief, wandering around to look and listen and get involved in issues. Try to keep the mind stable; in all your activities--eating, defecating, whatever--keep the mind centered within. If you know the state of the mind when it's centered, immovable, no longer wavering, no longer weak, then the basic level of the mind will be free and empty--empty of the things that would burn it, empty because there's no attachment. This is what enables you to ferret out the stability of the mind at every moment. It protects you from all sorts of things. All attachment to self, "me," and "them" is totally wiped out, cut away. The mind is entirely centered. If you can keep this state stable for the entire seven days, it will enable you to reach insight all on your own.

So I ask each of you to see whether or not you'll be able to make it all the way. Check to see how you're doing each day. And make sure you check things carefully. Don't let yourself be lax, sometimes stable, sometimes not. Get so that the mind is absolutely solid. Don't let yourself be weak. You have to be genuine in what you do if you want to reach the genuine extinguishing of suffering and stress. If you're not genuine, you'll end up letting yourself weaken in the face of the provocation of wanting this or wanting that, doing this or doing that, whatever, in the same way that you've been enslaved to desire, agitated by desire for who knows how long.

Your everyday life is where you can test yourself--so get back to the battlefield! Take a firm stance in neutrality. Then the objects that come into contact with the mind will be neutral; the mind itself will feel centered in neutrality. There will be nothing to take issue with in terms of good or bad or whatever. Everything will come to a halt in neutrality--because things in themselves aren't good or bad or self or whatever, simply that the mind has gone and made issues out of them.

So keep looking inward until you see the mind's neutrality and freedom from "self" continuously, and then you'll see how the lotus comes to bloom. If it hasn't bloomed yet, that's because it's withering and dry in the heat of the defilements, cravings, and attachments smoldering in the mind--things we'll have to learn to ferret out until we can disband them. If we don't, the lotus will wither away, its petals falling to the ground and simply rotting there. So make an effort to keep the lotus of the mind stable until it blooms. Don't wonder about what will happen as it blooms. Just keep it stable and make sure it isn't burned by the defilements.

The Battle Within

November 13, 1970

Today we are meeting as usual.

From what I've seen of your reports on your special development of mindfulness to read the facts within yourselves, some of you have really benefited in terms of penetrating in to read what's going on inside, and you've come out with correct understanding. So now I'd like to give you a further piece of advice: In developing mindfulness as a foundation for probing in to know the truth within yourself, you have to apply a level of effort and persistence appropriate to the task. This is because, as we all know, the mind is cloaked in defilements and mental effluents. If we don't train it and force it, it'll turn weak and lax. It won't have any strength. You have to make your persistence more and more constant so that your probing and investigating will be able to see all the way through to clear insight.

Clear insight doesn't come from thinking and speculating. It comes from investigating the mind while it's gathered into an adequate level of calm and stability. You look deeply into every aspect of the mind when it's neutral and calm, free from thought-formations or likes and dislikes for its preoccupations. You have to work at maintaining this state and at the same time probe deeply into it, because superficial knowledge isn't true knowledge. As long as you haven't probed deeply into the mind, you don't really know anything. The mind is simply calm on an external level, and your reading of the aspects of the wanderings of the mind under the influence of defilement, craving, and attachment isn't yet clear.

So you have to try to peer into yourself until you reach a level of awareness that can maintain its balance and let you contemplate your way to sharper understanding. If you don't contemplate so as to give rise to true knowledge, your mindfulness will stay just on the surface.

The same principle holds with contemplating the body. You have to probe deeply into the ways in which the body is repulsive and composed of physical elements. This is what it means to read the body so as to understand it, so that you can explore yourself in all your activities. This way you prevent your mind from straying off the path and keep it focused on seeing how it can burn away the defilements as they arise--which is very delicate work.

Being uncomplacent, not letting yourself get distracted by outside things, is what will make the practice go smoothly. It will enable you to examine the germs in the mind in a skillful way so that you can eliminate the subtlest ones: ignorance and delusion. Normally, we aren't fully aware of even the blatant germs, but now that the blatant ones are inactivated because of the mind's solid focus, we can look into the more profound areas to catch sight of the deceits of craving and defilements in whatever way they move into action. We watch them, know them, and are in a position to abandon them as soon as they wander off in search of sights, sounds, smells, and delicious flavors. Whether they're looking for good physical flavors--bodily pleasure--or good mental flavors, we have to know them from all sides, even though they're not easy to know because of all the many desires we feel for physical pleasure. And on top of that, there are the desires for happiness imbued with pleasurable feelings, perceptions that carry pleasurable feelings, thought-formations that carry pleasurable feelings, and consciousness that carries pleasurable feelings. All of these are nothing but desires for illusions, for things that deceive us into getting engrossed and distracted. As a result, it isn't easy for us to understand much of anything at all.

These are subtle matters and they all come under the term, "sensual craving"--the desire, lust, and love that provoke the mind into wandering out in search of the enjoyment it remembers from past sights, sounds, smells, tastes, and tactile sensations. Even though these things may have happened long ago, our perceptions bring them back to deceive us with ideas of their being good or bad. Once we latch onto them, they make the mind unsettled and defiled.

So it isn't easy to examine and understand all the various germs within the mind. The external things we're able to know and let go of are only the minor players. The important ones have gathered together to take charge in the mind and won't budge no matter how you try to chase them out. They're stubborn and determined to stay in charge. If you take them on when your mindfulness and discernment aren't equal to the fight, you'll end up losing your inner calm.

So you have to make sure that you don't push the practice too much, without at the same time letting it grow too slack. Find the Middle Way that's just right. While you're practicing in this way, you'll be able to observe what the mind is like when it has mindfulness and discernment in charge, and then you make the effort to maintain that state and keep it constant. That's when the mind will have the opportunity to stop and be still, stable and centered for long periods of time until it's used to being that way.

Now, there are some areas where we have to force the mind and be strict with it. If we're weak and lax, there's no way we can succeed, for we've given in to our own wants for so long already. If we keep giving in to them, it will become even more of a habit. So you have to use force--the force of your will and the force of your mindfulness and discernment. Even if you get to the point where you have to put your life on the line, you've got to be willing. When the time comes for you really to be serious, you've got to hold out until you come out winning. If you don't win, you don't give up. Sometimes you have to make a vow as a way of forcing yourself to overcome your stubborn desires for physical pleasure that tempt you and lead you astray.

If you're weak and settle for whatever pleasure comes in the immediate present, then when desire comes in the immediate present you fall right for it. If you give in to your wants often in this way, it'll become habitual, for defilement is always looking for the chance to tempt you, to incite you. As when we try to give up an addiction to betel, cigarettes, or meat: It's hard to do because craving is always tempting us. "Take just a little," it says. "Just a taste. It doesn't matter." Craving knows how to fool us, the way a fish is fooled into getting caught on a hook by the bait surrounding the hook, screwing up its courage enough to take just a little, and then a little more, and then a little more until it's sure to get snagged. The demons of defilement have us surrounded on all sides. Once we fall for their delicious flavors, we're sure to get snagged on the hook. No matter how much we struggle and squirm, we can't get free.

You have to realize that gaining victory over your enemies--the cravings and defilements in the heart--is no small matter, no casual affair. You can't let yourself be weak or lax, but you also have to gauge your strength, for you have to figure out how to apply your efforts at abandoning and destroying to weaken the defilements and cravings that have had the power of demons overwhelming the mind for so long. It's not the case that you have to battle to the brink of death in every area. With some things--such as giving up addictions--you can mount a full-scale campaign and come out winning without killing yourself in the process. But with other things, more subtle and deep, you have to be more perceptive so as to figure out how to overcome them over the long haul, digging up their roots so that they gradually weaken to the point where your mindfulness and discernment can rise above them. If there are any areas where you're still losing out, you have to take stock of your sensitivities to figure out why. Otherwise, you'll keep losing out, for when the defilements really want something, they trample all over your mindfulness and discernment in their determination to get what they're after: "That's what I want. I don't care what anyone says." They really are that stubborn! So it's no small matter, figuring out how to bring them under control. It's like running into an enemy or a wild beast rushing in to devour you. What are you going to do?

When the defilements arise right before your eyes, you have to be wary. Suppose you're perfectly aware, and all of a sudden they spring up and confront you: What kind of mindfulness and discernment are you going to use to disband them, to realize that, "These are the hordes of Mara, come to burn and eat me. How am I going to get rid of them?" In other words, how are you going to find a skillful way of contemplating them so as to destroy them right then and there?

We have to do this regardless of whether we're being confronted with physical and mental pain or physical and mental pleasure. Actually, pleasure is more treacherous than pain because it's hard to fathom and easy to fall for. As for pain, no one falls for it because it's so uncomfortable. So how are we going to contemplate so as to let go of both the pleasure and the pain? This is the problem we're faced with at every moment. It's not the case that when we practice we accept only the pleasure and stop when we run into pain. That's not the case at all. We have to learn how to read both sides, to see that the pain is inconstant and stressful, and that the pleasure is inconstant and stressful, too. We have to penetrate clear through these things. Otherwise, we'll be deluded by the deceits of the cravings that want pleasure, whether it's physical pleasure or whatever. Our every activity--sitting, standing, walking, lying down--is really for the sake of pleasure, isn't it?

This is why there are so many, many ways in which we're deluded with pleasure. Whatever we do, we do for the sake of pleasure without realizing how deeply we've mired ourselves in suffering and stress. When we contemplate inconstancy, stress, and not-selfness, we don't get anywhere in our contemplation because we haven't seen through pleasure. We still think that it's a good thing. We have to probe into the fact that there's no real ease to physical or mental pleasure. It's all stress. When you can see it from this angle, that's when you'll come to understand inconstancy.

Then once the mind isn't focused on wanting pleasure all the time, its stresses and pains will lighten. It will be able to see them as something common and normal, to see that if you try to change the pains to find ease, there's no ease to be found. In this way, you won't be overly concerned with trying to change the pains, for you'll see that there's no pleasure or ease to the aggregates, that they give nothing but stress and pain. As in the Buddha's teachings we chant every day: "Form is stressful, feeling, perception, thought-formations, and consciousness are all stressful." The problem is that we haven't investigated into the truth of our own form, feelings, perceptions, thought-formations, and consciousness. Our insight isn't yet penetrating because we haven't looked from the angle of true knowing. And so we get deluded here and lost there in our search for pleasure, finding nothing but pain and yet mistaking it for pleasure. This shows that we still haven't opened our ears and eyes; we still don't know the truth. Once we do know the truth, though, the mind will be more inclined to grow still and calm than to go wandering off. The reason it goes wandering off is because it's looking for pleasure, but once it realizes there's no real pleasure to be found in that way, it settles down and grows still.

All the cravings that provoke and unsettle the mind come down to nothing but the desire for pleasure. So we have to contemplate so as to see that the aggregates have no pleasure to offer, that they're stressful by their very nature. They're not us or ours. Take them apart and have a good look at them, starting with the body. Analyze the body down to its elements so that the mind won't keep latching onto it as "me" or "mine." You have to do this over and over again until you really understand.

It's the same as when we chant the passage for Recollection while Using the Requisites--food, clothing, shelter, and medicine--every day. We do this so as to gain real understanding. If we don't do this every day, we forget and get deluded into loving and worrying about the body as "my body," "my self." No matter how much we keep latching onto it over and over again, it's not easy for us to realize what we're doing, even though we have the Buddha's teachings available, explaining these things in every way. Or we may have contemplated to some extent, but we haven't seen things clearly. We've seen only in a vague and blurry way and then flitted off oblivious without having probed in to see all the way through. This is because the mind isn't firmly centered. It isn't still. It keeps wandering off to find things to think about and get itself all agitated. This way it can't really get to know anything at all. All it knows are a few little perceptions. This is the way it has been for who knows how many years now. It's as if our vision has been clouded by spots that we haven't yet removed from our eyes.

Those who aren't interested in exploring, who don't make an effort to get to the facts, don't wonder about anything at all. They're free from doubt, all right, but it's because their doubts have been smothered by delusion. If we start exploring and contemplating, we'll have to wonder about the things we don't yet know: "What's this? What does it mean? How should I deal with it?" These are questions that lead us to explore. If we don't explore, it's because we don't have any intelligence. Or we may gain a few little insights, but we let them pass so that we never explore deeply into the basic principles of the practice. What little we do know doesn't go anywhere, doesn't penetrate into the Noble Truths, because our mindfulness and discernment run out of strength. Our persistence isn't resilient enough, isn't brave enough. We don't dare look deeply inside ourselves.

To go by our own estimates of how far is enough in the practice is to lie to ourselves. It keeps us from gaining release from suffering and stress. If you happen to come up with a few insights, don't go bragging about them, or else you'll end up deceiving yourself in countless ways. Those who really know, even when they have attained the various stages of insight, are heedful to keep on exploring. They don't get stuck on this stage or that. Even when their insights are correct they don't stop right there and start bragging, for that's the way of a fool.

Intelligent people, even though they see things clearly, always keep an eye out for the enemies lying in wait for them on the deeper, more subtle levels ahead. They have to keep penetrating further and further in. They have no sense that this or that level is plenty enough--for how can it be enough? The defilements are still burning away, so how can you brag? Even though your knowledge may be true, how can you be complacent when your mind has yet to establish a foundation for itself?

As you investigate with mindfulness and discernment, complacency is the major problem. You have to be uncomplacent in the practice if you want to keep up with the fact that life is ebbing away, ebbing with every moment. And how should you live so that you can be said to be uncomplacent? This is an extremely important question, for if you're not alive to it, then no matter how many days or months you practice meditation or restraint of the senses, it's simply a temporary exercise. When you're done, you get back to your same old turmoil as before.

And watch out for your mouth. You'll have trouble not bragging, for the defilements will provoke you into speaking. They want to speak, they want to brag, they won't let you stay silent.

If you force yourself in the practice without understanding its true aims, you end up deceiving yourself and go around telling people, "I practiced in silence for so many days, so many months." This is deceiving yourself and others as well. The truth of the matter is that you're still a slave to stupidity, obeying the many levels of defilement and craving within yourself without realizing the fact. If someone praises you, you really prick up your ears, wag your tail and, instead of explaining the harm of the defilements and craving you were able to find within yourself, you simply want to brag.

So the practice of the Dhamma isn't something that you can just muddle your way through. It's something you have to do with your intelligence fully alert--for when you contemplate in a circumspect way, you'll see that there's nothing worth getting engrossed in, that everything--both inside and out--is nothing but an illusion. It's like being adrift, alone in the middle of the ocean with no island or shore in sight. Can you afford just to sit back and relax, to make a temporary effort and then brag about it? Of course not! As your investigation penetrates inwardly to ever more subtle levels of the mind, you'll have to become more and more calm and reserved, in the same way that people become more and more circumspect as they grow from children to teenagers and into adults. Your mindfulness and discernment have to keep growing more and more mature in order to understand the right and wrong, the true and false, in whatever arises: That's what will enable you to let go and gain release. And that's what will make your life in the true practice of the Dhamma go smoothly. Otherwise, you'll fool yourself into boasting of how many years you practiced meditation and will eventually find yourself worse off than before, with defilement flaring up in a big way. If this is the way you go, you'll end up tumbling head over heels into fire--for when you raise your head in pride, you run into the flames already burning within yourself.

To practice means to use the fire of mindfulness and discernment as a counter-fire to put out the blaze of the defilements, because the heart and mind are burning with defilement, and when we use the fire of mindfulness and discernment to put out the fire of defilement, the mind can cool down. Do this by being increasingly honest with yourself, without leaving an opening for defilement and craving to insinuate their way into control. You have to be alert. Circumspect. Wise to them. Don't fall for them! If you fall for whatever rationale they come up with, it means that your mindfulness and discernment are still weak. They lead you away by the nose, burning you with their fire right before your very eyes, and yet you're still able to open your mouth to brag!

So turn around and take stock of everything within yourself. Take stock of every aspect, because right and wrong, true and false, are all within you. You can't go finding them outside. The damaging things people say about you are nothing compared to the damage caused inside you when defilement burns you, when your feeling of "me" and "mine" raises its head.

If you don't honestly come to your senses, there's no way your practice of the Dhamma can gain you release from the great mass of suffering and stress. You may be able to gain a little knowledge and let go of a few things, but the roots of the problem will still lie buried deep down. So you have to dig them out. You can't relax after little bouts of emptiness and equanimity. That won't accomplish anything. The defilements and mental effluents lie deep in the personality, so you have to use mindfulness and discernment to penetrate deep down to make a precise and thorough examination. Only then will you get results. Otherwise, if you stay only on the surface level, you can practice until your body lies rotting in its coffin but you won't have changed any of your basic habits.

Those who are scrupulous by nature, who know how to contemplate their own flaws, will keep on the alert for any signs of pride within themselves. They'll try to control and destroy conceit on every side and won't allow it to swell. The methods we need to use in the practice for examining and destroying the germs within the mind aren't easy to master. For those who don't contemplate themselves thoroughly, the practice may actually only increase their pride, their bragging, their desire to go teaching others. But if we turn within and discern the deceits and conceits of self, a profound feeling of disenchantment and dismay arises, causing us to pity ourselves for our own stupidity, for the amount to which we've deluded ourselves all along, and for how much effort we'll still need to put into the practice.

So however great the pain and anguish, however many tears bathe your cheeks, persevere! The practice isn't simply a matter of looking for mental and physical pleasure. "Let tears bathe my cheeks, but I'll keep on with my striving at the holy life as long as I live!" That's the way it has to be! Don't quit at the first small difficulty with the thought, "It's a waste of time. I'd do better to follow my cravings and defilements." You can't think like that! You have to take the exact opposite stance: "When they tempt me to grab this, take a lot of that--I won't! However fantastic the object may be, I won't take the bait." Make a firm declaration! This is the only way to get results. Otherwise, you'll never work yourself free, for the defilements have all sorts of tricks up their sleeves. If you get wise to one trick, they simply change to another, and then another.

If we're not observant to see how much we've been deceived by the defilements in all sorts of ways, we won't come to know the truth within ourselves. Other people may fool us now and then, but the defilements fool us all of the time. We fall for them and follow them hook, line, and sinker. Our trust in the Lord Buddha is nothing compared to our trust in them. We're disciples of the demons of craving, letting them lead us ever deeper into their jungle.

If we don't contemplate to see this for ourselves, we're lost in that jungle charnel ground where the demons keep roasting us to make us squirm with desires and every form of distress. Even though you have come to stay in a place with few disturbances, these demons still manage to tempt and draw you away. Just notice how the saliva flows when you come across anything delicious! So you have to decide to be either a warrior or a loser. The practice requires that you do battle with defilements and cravings. Always be on your guard, whatever the approach they take to seduce and deceive you. Other people can't come in to lead you away, but these demons of your own defilements can, because you're willing to trust them, to be their slave. You have to contemplate yourself carefully so that you're no longer enslaved to them and can reach total freedom within yourself. Make an effort to develop your mindfulness and discernment so as to gain clear insight and then let go until suffering and stress disband in every way.

All Things Are Unworthy of Attachment

November 21, 1970

Today's our day to discuss the practice.

It's very beneficial that we have practiced the Dhamma by contemplating ourselves step by step and have--to some extent--come to know the truth. This is because each person has to find the truth within: the truths of stress, its cause, and the path leading to its disbanding. If we don't know these things, we fall into the same sufferings as the rest of the world. We may have come to live in a Dhamma center, yet if we don't know these truths we don't benefit from staying here. The only way we differ from living at home is that we're observing the precepts. If we don't want to be deluded in our practice, these truths are things we have to know. Otherwise, we get deluded into looking for our fun in the stresses and sufferings offered by the world.

Our practice is to contemplate until we understand stress and its cause, in other words, the defilements that have power and authority in the heart and mind. It's only because we have this practice that we can disband these defilements, that we can disband stress every day and at all times. This is something really marvelous. Those who don't practice don't have a clue, even though they live enveloped by defilements and stress. They simply get led around by the nose into more and more suffering, and yet none of them realize what's going on. If we don't make contact with the Dhamma, if we don't practice, we go through birth and death simply to create kamma with one another and to keep whirling around in suffering and stress.

We have to contemplate until we really see stress: That's when we'll become uncomplacent and try to disband it or to gain release from it. The practice is thus a matter of struggling to gain victory over stress and suffering with better and better results each time. Whatever mistakes we make in whatever way, we have to try not to make them again. And we have to contemplate the harm and suffering caused by the more subtle defilements, cravings, and attachments within us. This is why we have to probe into the deeper, more profound parts of the heart--for if we stay only on the superficial levels of emptiness in the mind, we won't gain any profound knowledge at all.

So we train the mind to be mindful and firmly centered, and to fix its focus on looking within, knowing within. Don't let it get distracted outside. When it focuses within, it will come to know the truth: the truth of stress and of the causes of stress--defilement, craving, and attachment--as they arise. It will see what they're like and how to probe inward to disband them

When all is said and done, the practice comes down to one issue, because it focuses exclusively on one thing: stress together with its cause. This is the central issue in human life--even animals are in the same predicament--but our ignorance deludes us into latching onto all kinds of things. This is because of our misunderstandings or wrong views. If we gain Right View, we see things correctly. Whenever we see stress, we see its truth. When we see the cause of stress, we see its truth. We both know and see because we've focused on it. If you don't focus on stress, you won't know it; but as soon as you focus on it, you will. It's because the mind hasn't focused here that it wanders out oblivious, chasing after its preoccupations.

When we try to focus it down, it struggles and resists because it's used to wandering. But if we keep focusing it again and again, more and more frequently until we get a sense of how to bring it under control, then the task ultimately becomes easier because the mind no longer struggles to chase after its preoccupations as it did before. No matter how much it resists when we start training it, eventually we're sure to bring it under our control, getting it to settle down and be still. If it doesn't settle down, you have to contemplate it. You have to show it that you mean business. This is because defilement and craving are very strong. You can't be weak when dealing with them. You have to be brave, to have a fight-to-the-death attitude, and to keep sustaining your efforts. If you're concerned only with finding comfort and pleasure, the day will never come when you'll gain release. You'll have to continue staying under their power.

Their power envelops everything in our character, making it very difficult for us to find out the truth about ourselves. What we do know is just a smattering, and so we play truant, abandoning the task, and end up seeing that the practice of the Dhamma isn't really important. Thus we don't bother to be strict with ourselves, and instead involve ourselves in all kinds of things, for that's the path the defilements keep pointing out to us. We grope along weakly, making it harder and harder to see stress clearly because we keep giving in to the defilements and taking their bait. When they complain about the slightest discomfort, we quickly pander to them and take the bait again. It's because we're so addicted to the bait that we don't appreciate either the power of craving--as it wanders out after sights, sounds, smells, tastes, etc.--or the harm it causes in making us scattered and restless, unable to stay still and contemplate ourselves. It's always finding things for us to do, to think about, making ourselves suffer, and yet we remain blind to the fact.

Now that we've come to practice the Dhamma, we begin to have a sense of what's going on. For this reason, whoever practices without being complacent will find that defilement and stress will have to grow lighter and lighter, step by step. The areas where we used to be defeated, we now come out victorious. Where we used to be burned by the defilements, we now have the mindfulness and discernment to burn them instead. Only when we stop groping around and really come to our senses will we realize the benefits of the Dhamma, the importance of the practice. Then there is no way that we can abandon the practice, for something inside us keeps forcing us to stay with it. We've seen that if we don't practice to disband defilement and stress, the stress of the defilements will keep piling up. This is why we have to stay with the practice to our last breath.

You have to be firm in not letting yourself be weak and easily led astray. Those who are mindful and discerning will naturally act it this way; those who aren't will keep on following their defilements, ending up back where they were when they hadn't yet started practicing to gain release from stress. They may keep on practicing, but it's hard to tell what they're practicing for--mostly for more stress. This shows that they're still groping around--and when they grope around in this way, they start criticizing the practice as useless and bad.

When a person submits readily to defilement and craving, there's no way she can practice, for if you're going to practice, there are a lot of things you have to struggle with and endure. It's like paddling a boat against the stream--you have to use strength if you want to make any headway. It's not easy to go against the stream of the defilements, because they are always ready to pull you down to a lower level. If you aren't mindful and discerning, if you don't use the Lord Buddha's Dhamma to examine yourself, your strength will fail you, for if you have only a little mindfulness and discernment in the face of a lot of defilements, they'll make you vacillate. And if you're living with sweet-talking sycophants, you'll go even further off the path, involved with all sorts of things and oblivious to the practice.

To practice the Dhamma, then, is to go against the flow, to go upstream against suffering and stress, because suffering and stress are the main problems. If you don't really contemplate stress, your practice will go nowhere. Stress is where you start, and then you try to trace out its root cause. You have to use your discernment to track down exactly where stress originates, for stress is a result. Once you see the result, you have to track down the cause. Those who are mindful and discerning are never complacent. Whenever stress arises they're sure to search out its causes so that they can eliminate them. This sort of investigation can proceed on many levels, from the coarse to the refined, and requires that you seek advice so that you don't stumble. Otherwise, you may think you can figure it all out in your head--which won't work at all!

The basic Dhamma principles that the Lord Buddha proclaimed for us to use in our contemplation are many, but there's no need to learn them all. Just focusing on some of the more important ones, such as the five aggregates or name and form, will be very useful. But you need to keep making a thorough, all-round examination, not just an occasional probe, so that a feeling of dispassion and disengagement arises and loosens the grip of desire. Use mindfulness to keep constant and close supervision over the senses, and that mindfulness will come to be more present than your tendency to drift off elsewhere. Regardless of what you're doing, saying, or thinking, be on the lookout for whatever will make you slip, for if you're tenacious in sustaining mindfulness, that's how all your stresses and sufferings can be disbanded.

So keep at this. If you fall down 100 times, get back up 100 times and resume your stance. The reason mindfulness and discernment are slow to develop is because you're not really sensitive to yourself. The greater your sensitivity, the stronger your mindfulness and discernment will become. As the Lord Buddha said, "Bhavita bahulikata"--which means, "Develop and maximize"--i.e., make the most of your mindfulness.

The way your practice has developed through contemplating and supervising the mind throughout your daily life has already shown its rewards to some extent, so keep stepping up your efforts. Don't let yourself grow weak or lax. You've finally got this opportunity: Can you afford to be complacent? Your life is steadily ebbing away, so you have to compensate by building up more and more mindfulness and discernment until you become mature in the Dhamma. Otherwise, your defilements will remain many and your discernment crude. The older you grow, the more you have to watch out--for we know what happens to old people everywhere.

So seize the moment to develop the faculties of conviction, persistence, mindfulness, concentration, and discernment in a balanced way. Keep contemplating and probing, and you'll protect yourself from wandering out after the world. No matter who tempts you to go with them, you can be sure within yourself that you won't go following them because you no longer have to go believing anyone else or hoping for the baits of the world--because the baits of the world are poison. The Dhamma has to be the refuge and light of your life. Once you have this degree of conviction in yourself, you can't help but stride forward without slipping back; but if you waver and wander, unsure of whether or not to keep practicing the Dhamma, watch out: You're sure to get pulled over the cliff and into the pit of fire.

If you aren't free within yourself, you get pulled at from all sides because the world is full of things that keep pulling at you. But those who have the intelligence not to be gullible will see the stress and harm of those things distinctly for themselves. For this reason they're not headed for anything low; they won't have to keep suffering in the world. They feel dispassion. They lose their taste for all the various baits and lures the world has to offer.

The practice of the Dhamma is what allows us to shake off whatever attractive things used to delude us into holding on. Realize that it won't be long before we die--we won't be here much longer!--so even if anyone offers us incredible wealth, why should we want it? Who could really own it? Who could really control it?

If you can read yourself in this matter, you come to a feeling of dispassion. Disenchantment. You lose your taste for all the lures of the world. You no longer hold them in esteem. If you make use of them, it's for the sake of the benefits they give in terms of the Dhamma, but your disenchantment stays continuous. Even the name and form you've been regarding as "me" and "mine" have been wearing down and falling apart continually. As for the defilements, they're still lying in wait to burn you. So how can you afford to be oblivious? First there's the suffering and stress of the five aggregates, and on top of that there's the suffering and stress caused by defilement, craving, and attachment, stabbing you, slapping you, beating you.

The more you practice and contemplate, the more you become sensitive to this on deeper and deeper levels. Your interest in blatant things outside--good and bad people, good and bad things--gets swept away. You don't have to concern yourself with them, for you're concerned solely with penetrating yourself within, destroying your pride and conceit. Outside affairs aren't important. What's important is how clearly you can see the truth inside until the brightness appears.

The brightness that comes from seeing the truth isn't at all like the light we see outside. Once you really know it, you see that it's indescribable, for it's something entirely personal. It cleans everything out of the heart and mind in line with the strength of our mindfulness and discernment. It's what sweeps and cleans and clears and lets go and disbands things inside. But if we don't have mindfulness and discernment as our means of knowing, contemplating, and letting go, then everything inside is dark on all sides. And not only dark, but also full of fire whose poisonous fuel keeps burning away. What could be more terrifying than the fuel burning inside us? Even though it's invisible, it flares up every time there's sensory contact.

The bombs they drop on people to wipe them out aren't really all that dangerous, for you can die only once per lifetime. But the three bombs of passion, aversion, and delusion keep ripping the heart apart countless times. Normally we don't realize how serious the damage is, but when we come to practice the Dhamma we can take stock of the situation, seeing what it's like when sensory contact comes, at what moments the burning heat of defilement and craving arises, and why they're all so very quick.

When you contemplate how to disband suffering and defilement, you need the proper tools and have to make the effort without being complacent. The fact that we've come to practice out here without any involvements or worldly responsibilities helps speed up the practice. It's extremely beneficial in helping us to examine our inner diseases in detail and to disband suffering and stress continually in line with our mindfulness and discernment. Our burdens grow lighter and we come to realize how much our practice of the Dhamma is progressing in the direction of the cessation of suffering.

Those who don't have the time to come and rest here or to really stop, get carried away with all kinds of distractions. They may say, "I can practice anywhere," but it's just words. The fact of the matter is that their practice is to follow the defilements until their heads are spinning, and yet they can still boast that they can practice anywhere! Their mouths aren't in line with their minds, and their minds--burned and beaten by defilement, craving, and attachment--don't realize their situation. They're like worms that live in filth and are happy to stay and die right there in the filth.

People with any mindfulness and discernment feel disgust at the filth of the defilements in the mind. The more they practice, the more sensitive they become, the more their revulsion grows. Before, when our mindfulness and discernment were still crude, we didn't feel this at all. We were happy to play around in the filth within ourselves. But now that we've come to practice, to contemplate from the blatant to the more subtle levels, we sense more and more how disgusting the filth really is. There's nothing to it that's worth falling for at all, because it's all inconstancy, stress, and not-self.

So what's there to want out of life? Those who are ignorant say that we're born to gain wealth and be millionaires, but that kind of life is like falling into hell! If you understand the practice of the Dhamma in the Buddha's footsteps, you realize that nothing is worth having, nothing is worth getting involved with, everything has to be let go.

Those who still latch onto the body, feeling, perceptions, thought-formations, and consciousness as self need to contemplate until they see that the body is stressful, feelings are stressful, perceptions are stressful, thought-formations are stressful, consciousness is stressful--in short, name is stressful and so is form, or in even plainer terms, the body is stressful and so is the mind. You have to focus on stress. Once you see it thoroughly, from the blatant to the subtle levels, you'll be able to rise above pleasure and pain because you've let them go. But if you have yet to fully understand stress, you'll still yearn for pleasure--and the more you yearn, the more you suffer.

This holds too for the pleasure that comes when the mind is tranquil. If you let yourself get stuck on it, you're like a person addicted to a drug: Once there's the desire, you take the drug and think yourself happy. But as for how much suffering the repeated desire causes, you don't have the intelligence to see it. All you see is that if you take the drug whenever you want, you're okay.

When people can't shake off their addictions, this is why. They get stuck on the sense of pleasure that comes when they take the drug. They're ingesting sensuality and they keep on wanting more, for only when they ingest more will their hunger subside. But soon it comes back again, so they'll want still more. They keep on ingesting sensuality, stirring up the mind, but don't see that there's any harm or suffering involved. Instead, they say they're happy When the longing gets really intense, it feels really good to satisfy it. That's what they say. People who have heavy defilements and crude discernment don't see that desire and longing are suffering, and so they don't know how to do away with them. As soon as they take what they want, the desire goes away. Then it comes back again, so they take some more. It comes back again and they take still more--over and over like this, so blind that they don't realize anything at all.